Contract or permanent? What to weigh up as an engineer
Many engineers reach a point where they wonder whether contracting would suit them better than a permanent job, or the other way round. Neither is right for everyone. Here are the main things to weigh up.
Pay and how you’re paid
Contract day rates are usually higher than the equivalent permanent salary, because contractors don’t get paid holidays, sick pay, a pension contribution or other benefits, and there can be gaps between contracts. When comparing, think about your annual earnings across a realistic number of working days, not just the daily rate.
How you’re paid also matters. Contractors might work through an umbrella company, their own limited company, or directly on PAYE, and IR35 rules affect how much tax you pay depending on how the role is set up. Our IR35 page explains the options in more detail.
Security and stability
Permanent roles offer more predictable income, employment rights built up over time, and usually a clearer path to promotion. Contracts can end at short notice or not be renewed when a project finishes. If you have a mortgage application coming up or simply value certainty, that’s worth factoring in.
Variety and experience
Contracting can be a fast way to build broad experience, with different employers, products, systems and ways of working in a short time. Many contractors enjoy the variety and the focus on delivering a specific project. Permanent roles, on the other hand, let you go deeper, see projects through from start to finish and build long-term relationships within a team.
Career development
Permanent employers are more likely to invest in your training, chartership or professional qualifications. As a contractor, keeping your skills current is mostly down to you, and you’ll usually be expected to hit the ground running.
Questions to ask yourself
- Could I cover a month or two without work between contracts?
- Am I comfortable handling my own tax, pension and admin, or paying someone to?
- Do I want variety, or depth and progression in one organisation?
- Are my skills in demand enough to keep me in regular contracts?
Talk it through with us
Mydas recruits for both contract and permanent engineering and technical roles across Northern Ireland, so we can give you an honest view of the market for your skills either way. Browse our current jobs or submit your CV and we’ll be in touch.